You are here

High Court of Lesotho decisions

December 2004

R v Mohale and Another (CRI/T/12/2003) (CRI/T/12/2003) [2004] LSHC 155 (13 December 2004);

June 2004

Malebo v Minister of Information & Broadcasting and Another (CIV/T/89/96 ) (CIV/T/89/96) [2004] LSHC 78 (15 June 2004);

March 2004

Tsekoa v Mokhathi (CIV/APN/26/2004 CIV/APN/34/2004) (CIV/APN/26/2004) [2004] LSHC 39 (02 March 2004);

February 2004

Faesa v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/APN/445/03) (CRI/APN/445/03) [2004] LSHC 26 (13 February 2004);

September 2004

Mochaba v Tikiso (CIV/APN/277/2004) (CIV/APN/277/2004) [2004] LSHC 111 (15 September 2004);

March 2004

Malachamela v Sekheo and Others (CIV/APN/376/03) (CIV/APN/376/03) [2004] LSHC 44 (08 March 2004);

December 2004

Mothuntsane v Mothuntsane and Another (CIV/APN/67/2003) (CIV/APN/67/2003) [2004] LSHC 159 (17 December 2004);

October 2004

Mosili and Others v R (C of A (CRI) No. 5 of 2001 ) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 127 (20 October 2004);

Salat Enterprises (Pty) Ltd v Conspiracy Fashions Lesotho Ltd and Others (CIV/T/340/2004 ) (CIV/T/340/2004) [2004] LSHC 124 (18 October 2004);

March 2004

National Executive Committee of the Basutoland African Congress and Another v Mandoro (CIV/APN/69/2004) (CIV/APN/69/2004) [2004] LSHC 38 (02 March 2004);

August 2004

Maleke v Lesotho National General Insurance Company Limited and Another (CIV/APN/294/2001 ) (CIV/APN/294/2001) [2004] LSHC 104 (31 August 2004);

October 2004

Moletsane and Others v Attorney General and Another (CIV/APN/163/2001) (CIV/APN/163/2001) [2004] LSHC 123 (18 October 2004);

February 2004

R v Nkoe (Rev. Case No. 10/04 CR 190/2004 Rev. Order No. 1/04 ) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 27 (13 February 2004);

October 2004

R v Khatitsita (CRI/T/98/2002 ) (CRI/T/98/2002) [2004] LSHC 126 (19 October 2004);

February 2004

Lehloenya Mokokoane v Mokokoane and Others (CIV/APN/4/04 ) (CIV/APN/4/04) [2004] LSHC 37 (27 February 2004);

Lelosa v Lekhanya (CIV/T/3/1992 ) (CIV/T/3/1992) [2004] LSHC 36 (25 February 2004);

December 2004

R v Monatsi and Others (CRI/T/22/96) (CRI/T/22/96) [2004] LSHC 156 (15 December 2004);

July 2004

Serabele and Others v Director of Public Prosecution (CIV/APN/333/2004 ) (CIV/APN/333/2004) [2004] LSHC 87 (14 July 2004);

November 2004

Tuoane v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/APN/499/04 ) (CRI/APN/499/04) [2004] LSHC 139 (08 November 2004);

Makatjane v Public Service Commission Minister of Health and Others (CIV/APN/274/04 ) (CIV/APN/274/04) [2004] LSHC 148 (25 November 2004);

Lephole v Editor - Mohlanka (Newspaper) and Another (CIV/T/93/96) (CIV/T/93/96) [2004] LSHC 146 (22 November 2004);

February 2004

Lesotho Bank v Matabane (CIV/APN/228/2003 ) (CIV/APN/228/2003) [2004] LSHC 22 (08 February 2004);

October 2004

Moosa v Maseru City Council and Another (C. OF A.(CIV)NO.5 04CIV/APN/2/04) (CIV/APN/2/04) [2004] LSHC 121 (15 October 2004);

February 2004

Lesotho Bank v Maseretse (CIV/APN/52/2003) (CIV/APN/52/2003) [2004] LSHC 21 (08 February 2004);

April 2004

Leoma v Leoma (CofA(CIV)No. 19 of 2003) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 61 (07 April 2004);

February 2004

R v Namane (CRI/T/61/03) (CRI/T/61/03) [2004] LSHC 32 (20 February 2004);

September 2004

R v Makhasane and Others (CRI/T/03/2004 ) (CRI/T/03/2004) [2004] LSHC 116 (28 September 2004);

December 2004

Asman v His Worship Magistrate Makara and Others (CIV/APN/466/2004) (CIV/APN/466/2004) [2004] LSHC 149 (02 December 2004);

July 2004

Majalle v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/APN/402/2004) (CRI/APN/402/2004) [2004] LSHC 84 (05 July 2004);

January 2004

Dorcas Aid South Africa v Dorcas Aid International Lesotho (CIV/APN/473/2003) (CIV/APN/473/2003) [2004] LSHC 15 (08 January 2004);

December 2004

Mona v Khoarai and Another (CIV/APN/196/2000 ) (CIV/APN/196/2000) [2004] LSHC 150 (08 December 2004);

November 2004

Ramothibe v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/A/23/04 CRI/258/03) (CRI/A/23/04) [2004] LSHC 143 (16 November 2004);

September 2004

Lenea v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/APN/517/04 ) (CRI/APN/517/04) [2004] LSHC 110 (09 September 2004);

March 2004

Jonathan v Minister of Home Affairs and Others (CIV/APN/281/96) (CIV/APN/281/96) [2004] LSHC 49 (19 March 2004);

December 2004

R v Maretlane (Rev. Case No.26/2003CR NO. 727/2002 Rev. Order No.24/2004) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 151 (08 December 2004);

November 2004

Mokalanyane v Presiding Officer (RLMP) and Others (CIV/APN/73/93) (CIV/APN/73/93) [2004] LSHC 136 (03 November 2004);

August 2004

Monaheng v Monaheng and Others (CIV/APN/193/1999) (CIV/APN/193/1999) [2004] LSHC 100 (20 August 2004);

April 2004

Lesotho National General Insurance Co Ltd v Tsiu (CASE NO. C OF A (CIV) 29/2004 ) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 64 (20 April 2004);

May 2004

Sekonyela and Others v Kopo and Another (CRI/APN/225/2004) (CRI/APN/225/2004) [2004] LSHC 72 (24 May 2004);

November 2004

R v Potse (CRI/T/69/99) (CRI/T/69/99) [2004] LSHC 145 (18 November 2004);

October 2004

R v Selibo and Others (C of A (CRI) NO 8/04 ) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 128 (20 October 2004);

May 2004

Kori and Others v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/APN/245/04CRI/APN/235/04) (CRI/APN/245/04) [2004] LSHC 68 (11 May 2004);

January 2004

R v Kabeli (Appeal Case No. CRI/A/2/2004 Criminal Case No. CR 531/01) (CRI/A/2/2004) [2004] LSHC 13 (01 January 2004);

July 2004

Molelle and Others v R (CRI/T/95/2002 ) (CRI/T/95/2002) [2004] LSHC 90 (27 July 2004);

Nthako v National Health Training Centre (The Director) (CIV/APN/278/04) (CIV/APN/278/04) [2004] LSHC 86 (13 July 2004);

October 2004

Tlali v Litaba and Others (CIV/ T/42/01 ) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 130 (26 October 2004);

January 2004

Khaka and Another v Pelesa and Others (duplicate of C027_0021) (CIV/APN/523/2004) (CIV/APN/523/2004) [2004] LSHC 17 (22 January 2004);

September 2004

khabo v Khabo (CIV/APN/526/04 CIV/T731/2003) (CIV/APN/526/04) [2004] LSHC 109 (08 September 2004);

August 2004

Senatla v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/APN/191/2004) (CRI/APN/191/2004) [2004] LSHC 98 (19 August 2004);

June 2004

R v Mohoasf (CRI/S/2/03 ) (CRI/S/2/03) [2004] LSHC 75 (04 June 2004);

September 2004

Fatane and Others v Crown ( not Sure) (Constitutional Case No. 3/01) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 114 (24 September 2004);

August 2004

TAM Industries (Pty) Ltd v Alfa Plant Hire (Pty) Ltd (CIV/T/495/2002) (CIV/T/495/2002) [2004] LSHC 106 (31 August 2004);

June 2004

Director of Public Prosecutions v Nthunya and Others (CRI/APN/122/2004) (CRI/APN/122/2004) [2004] LSHC 76 (08 June 2004);

August 2004

Thekiso v Mokatsanyane and Others (CIV/APN/460/2003 ) (CIV/APN/460/2003) [2004] LSHC 102 (25 August 2004);

February 2004

Notsi and Another v Her Worship, Mrs Mahamo and Others (CR/APN/41/2004) (CR/APN/41/2004) [2004] LSHC 20 (05 February 2004);

May 2004

Seemahale v Commissioner of Police and Others (CIV/APN/439/2003 ) (CIV/APN/439/2003) [2004] LSHC 66 (03 May 2004);

August 2004

Kelane v Director of Public Prosecution (CRI/APN/78/04 ) (CRI/APN/78/04) [2004] LSHC 96 (18 August 2004);

October 2004

Tlali v Litaba and Others (CIV/T/42/01) (CIV/T/42/01) [2004] LSHC 162 (21 October 2004);

February 2004

Qoabe v Director of Public Prosecutions ( CRI/APN/816/2003) (CRI/APN/816/2003) [2004] LSHC 18 (04 February 2004);

June 2004

Aqua Transport (Pty) Ltd v Ntseno and Others (CIV7APN/190/2004) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 81 (17 June 2004);

February 2004

Matheleli v Gama and Others (CIV/APN/457/00 CIV/T/247/00) (CIV/APN/457/00) [2004] LSHC 34 (24 February 2004);

November 2004

R v Ntai (CRI/T/110/2002) (CRI/T/110/2002) [2004] LSHC 144 (17 November 2004);

February 2004

Masokela v Commander RDLF and Another (CIV/APN/301/92) (CIV/APN/301/92) [2004] LSHC 28 (16 February 2004);

July 2004

Motoboli v Matete and Another (CIV/APN/288/04) (CIV/APN/288/04) [2004] LSHC 160 (17 July 2004);

February 2004

Motaboli v Director of Public Prosecutions and Others (CRI/APN/9/2004) (CRI/APN/9/2004) [2004] LSHC 31 (20 February 2004);

October 2004

R v kelello (Rev. Case No. 204/03 CR160/02 Rev. Order No. 23/04 ) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 129 (26 October 2004);

December 2004

Sole v Cull1nan and Others (C of A (CIV)29/2002) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 153 (10 December 2004);

March 2004

Mona v Lesotho Electricity Corporation (CIV/APN/465/03 ) (CIV/APN/465/03) [2004] LSHC 51 (22 March 2004);

August 2004

Moaki v Moaki and Others (CIV/APN/130/2004 ) (CIV/APN/130/2004) [2004] LSHC 92 (03 August 2004);

April 2004

Tlhabi v Commissioner of Police Presiding Officer and Others (C OF A (CIV) NO.24 OF 2003 CIV/APN/319/2003) (CIV/APN/319/2003) [2004] LSHC 54 (01 April 2004);

November 2004

R v Maphethekatsi and Others (CRI/T/213/2002) (CRI/T/213/2002) [2004] LSHC 147 (22 November 2004);

Letsie v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/APN/596/2004) (CRI/APN/596/2004) [2004] LSHC 134 (01 November 2004);

June 2004

Law Society of Lesotho v Right Honourable Prime Minister Pakalitha Mosisili N O and Others (Constitutional Case No. 2/04) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 82 (17 June 2004);

September 2004

R v Bolelekoa and Others (CRI/T/130/02) (CRI/T/130/02) [2004] LSHC 113 (23 September 2004);

March 2004

Molibeli v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/APN/730/03 ) (CRI/APN/730/03) [2004] LSHC 52 (29 March 2004);

August 2004

Matlanyane and Others v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/APN/192/2004 ) (CRI/APN/192/2004) [2004] LSHC 97 (19 August 2004);

April 2004

Khalanyane and Others v R (C of A (CRI) NO. 11 OF 2002) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 59 (07 April 2004);

October 2004

Ntai v Ntai and Others (CIV/APN/15/2003) (CIV/APN/15/2003) [2004] LSHC 131 (27 October 2004);

April 2004

Lesotho Revenue Authority v Master of the High Court and Others (CIV/APN/67/2004 ) (CIV/APN/67/2004) [2004] LSHC 55 (02 April 2004);

August 2004

R v Makhabane (Review Case No. 162/2004 CR. NO. 210/2004 Review Order No. 15/2004) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 105 (31 August 2004);

September 2004

Putsoane v Lesotho Highlands and Others (CIV/APN/401/04 ) (CIV/APN/401/04) [2004] LSHC 117 (29 September 2004);

August 2004

R v Sekhofa (Rev. Case No. 135/2004 CR. NO. 110/2004 Rev. Order No. 16/2004) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 101 (24 August 2004);

October 2004

Chabeli v Commissioner of Police and Another (CIV/T/150/97) (CIV/T/150/97) [2004] LSHC 125 (19 October 2004);

April 2004

Lahmeyer International GmbH v Crown (C of A (CRI) 6 OF 2002) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 60 (07 April 2004);

August 2004

Kambule v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/APN/516/04) (CRI/APN/516/04) [2004] LSHC 99 (20 August 2004);

July 2004

Morienyane v Morienyane and Others (CIV/APN/204/2003 ) (CIV/APN/204/2003) [2004] LSHC 83 (02 July 2004);

April 2004

R v Moratha and Others (CRI/APN/122/2000) (CRI/APN/122/2000) [2004] LSHC 56 (02 April 2004);

February 2004

Rataiane v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/APN/738/2003) (CRI/APN/738/2003) [2004] LSHC 33 (23 February 2004);

December 2004

R v Lehloka and Others (CRI/T/19/2004) (CRI/T/19/2004) [2004] LSHC 154 (13 December 2004);

February 2004

Ramabele v Maseela and Others (CIV/APN/223/03 CIV/APN/127/98) (CIV/APN/223/03) [2004] LSHC 29 (17 February 2004);

December 2004

R v Maphethekatsi and Others (CRI/T/213/2002 ) (CRI/T/213/2002) [2004] LSHC 152 (10 December 2004);

November 2004

Ramothibe v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/A/23/04, CRI/258/03) (CRI/A/23/04) [2004] LSHC 163 (16 November 2004);

March 2004

Mabathoana v Ministry of Tourism, Sports & Culture and Others (CIV/APN/219/2002 ) (CIV/APN/219/2002) [2004] LSHC 46 (10 March 2004);

August 2004

Seeiso v Seeiso and Others (CIV/APN/315/04 ) (CIV/APN/315/04) [2004] LSHC 94 (04 August 2004);

May 2004

Thamae v Moteo (CIV/APN/159/2003 ) (CIV/APN/159/2003) [2004] LSHC 67 (05 May 2004);

November 2004

B P Lesotho (Pty) Ltd v Mabathoana and Others (CIV/T/39/03) (CIV/T/39/03) [2004] LSHC 141 (15 November 2004);

April 2004

Liquidator Lesotho Bank v Khabo (Cof A (CIV) NO.22/03) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 62 (07 April 2004);

May 2004

R v Mositi (CRI/T/20/98) (CRI/T/20/98) [2004] LSHC 70 (19 May 2004);

October 2004

Thamae v Lesotho Bank and Another (CIV/APN/36/04) (CIV/APN/36/04) [2004] LSHC 120 (14 October 2004);

April 2004

Rakharebe v Commissioner of Police and Others (CIV/APN/4/03) (CIV/APN/4/03) [2004] LSHC 57 (06 April 2004);

February 2004

Nyamane v Mphalane and Others (CIV/APN/193/1999) (CIV/APN/193/1999) [2004] LSHC 24 (10 February 2004);

September 2004

Kaibe v Mofeli (CXV/APN/172/03) (CXV/APN/172/03) [2004] LSHC 107 (03 September 2004);

March 2004

Likoti v Commissioner of Police and Others (CIV/APN/332/2002) (CIV/APN/332/2002) [2004] LSHC 43 (08 March 2004);

ABSA Bank Limited v Latela (CIV/APN/466/01 ) (CIV/APN/466/01) [2004] LSHC 47 (16 March 2004);

July 2004

Lechesa v KPMG/Harley & Morris joint Venture and Others (CIV/APN/425/03) (CIV/APN/425/03) [2004] LSHC 88 (21 July 2004);

May 2004

R v Tutubala (CRI/T/200/2002 ) (CRI/T/200/2002) [2004] LSHC 73 (28 May 2004);

February 2004

R v Moeko (CRI/T/59/2002 ) (CRI/T/59/2002) [2004] LSHC 35 (24 February 2004);

March 2004

Lepetla v Makiietha and Another (CIV/APN/207/02) (CIV/APN/207/02) [2004] LSHC 48 (18 March 2004);

February 2004

Qefate v Director of Public Prosecutions (CRI/APN/873/2003) (CRI/APN/873/2003) [2004] LSHC 25 (10 February 2004);

September 2004

R v Lebone (Rev. Case No. 180/04 CR 1416/2004 (Maseru)Rev. Order No. 19/04) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 112 (22 September 2004);

January 2004

Makakole v Vodacom Lesotho (Pty) Ltd (Cof A (CIV)No.21/03 ) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 14 (01 January 2004);

October 2004

Humanitarian Relief Lesotho (fFormerly Dorcas Aid International Lesotho) and Another v Dorcas Aid International and Others (CIV/APN/236/04) (CIV/APN/236/04) [2004] LSHC 133 (29 October 2004);

December 2004

R v Malake (Rev. Case No.:234/04 CR 119/03 Rev. Order No.:25/04 ) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 158 (16 December 2004);

July 2004

Vodacom Lesotho (Pty) Ltd v Chatsane (CIV/T/108/04) (CIV/T/108/04) [2004] LSHC 161 (26 July 2004);

June 2004

Kali v Lesotho Telecommunications and Another (CIV/APN/301/2001) (CIV/APN/301/2001) [2004] LSHC 74 (03 June 2004);

March 2004

Monare v Diphoko and Others (CIV/APN/356/2002) (CIV/APN/356/2002) [2004] LSHC 53 (30 March 2004);

September 2004

Tsehlo v National Executive Committee and Another (CIV/APN/157/03 ) (CIV/APN/157/03) [2004] LSHC 108 (07 September 2004);

November 2004

W v W (CIV/T/344/2004) (CIV/T/344/2004) [2004] LSHC 137 (05 November 2004);

September 2004

R v Monyau (CRI/T/111/2002) (CRI/T/111/2002) [2004] LSHC 115 (27 September 2004);

January 2004

Machaha v Sekopo and Others (CIV/T/340/2000 ) (CIV/T/340/2000) [2004] LSHC 16 (16 January 2004);

June 2004

Lephole v Editor - Mohlanka (Newspaper) and Another (CIV/T/93/96) (CIV/T/93/96) [2004] LSHC 80 (16 June 2004);

March 2004

R v Andreas and Others (Review Case No. 36/04CR. No. 43/02 Rev. Order No.4/2004 ) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 50 (19 March 2004);

R v Thobi (Rev. Case No. 24/2004 CR. 191/2001 Rev. Order No. 3/2004 ) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 40 (03 March 2004);

April 2004

Mothae v Deputy Sheriff - Mr Monyako and Others (CIV/APN/92/2004) (CIV/APN/92/2004) [2004] LSHC 63 (16 April 2004);

August 2004

Motlomelo v Mathe and Others (CIV/APN/465A/03 ) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 95 (09 August 2004);

December 2004

Southern Lesotho Construction (Pty) Ltd v MNM Construction (Pty) Ltd and Others (CIV/APN/347/2004 ) (CIV/APN/347/2004) [2004] LSHC 157 (15 December 2004);

August 2004

Sebeko v Sebeko and Others (CIV/APN/286/04) (CIV/APN/286/04) [2004] LSHC 91 (02 August 2004);

February 2004

R v Morake (CRI/T/77/2000 ) (CRI/T/77/2000) [2004] LSHC 19 (04 February 2004);

March 2004

Malachamela v Sekheo and Others (CLV/APN/376/03) (CLV/APN/376/03) [2004] LSHC 45 (08 March 2004);

October 2004

Leteba v Leteba (CIV/APN/170/2004 CIV/APN/88/2004) (CIV/APN/170/2004) [2004] LSHC 122 (18 October 2004);

November 2004

R v Toloane (CRI/T/12/97) (CRI/T/12/97) [2004] LSHC 142 (15 November 2004);

May 2004

R v Sakoane and Another (CRI/T7234/02 ) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 71 (24 May 2004);

October 2004

R v Ndondozela (Rev. Case No 202/2004 CR 1763/2004 Rev. Order No 20/2004) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 118 (11 October 2004);

February 2004

Nts'oane and Another v Crown (CR/264/98 REV/ll/2004) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 30 (18 February 2004);

July 2004

Maphathe and Another v Maphathe NO and Others (CIV/APN/479/02) (CIV/APN/479/02) [2004] LSHC 89 (22 July 2004);

March 2004

Makharilele and Others v National Executive Committee -Lesotho Congress for Democracy and Others (CIV/APN/82/01 ) (CIV/APN/82/01) [2004] LSHC 42 (05 March 2004);

February 2004

Kolobe v Hoohlo (CIV/APN/10/04) (CIV/APN/10/04) [2004] LSHC 23 (10 February 2004);

November 2004

Mohola v Mahamo (CIV/APN/292/04) (CIV/APN/292/04) [2004] LSHC 140 (12 November 2004);

June 2004

Katz v Letseng Diamond (Pty) Ltd and Another (CIV/APN/22/2003 ) (CIV/APN/22/2003) [2004] LSHC 77 (15 June 2004);

November 2004

Matjama v Matjama (CIV/APN/255/00) (CIV/APN/255/00) [2004] LSHC 135 (03 November 2004);

June 2004

R v Selibo and Others (CRI/T/103/01) (CRI/T/103/01) [2004] LSHC 79 (15 June 2004);

October 2004

Tsiu v Lesotho National General Insurance Company Limited (CIV/T/84/97) (CIV/T/84/97) [2004] LSHC 132 (27 October 2004);

November 2004

Thai v Director of Public Prosecution (CRI/APN/617/04) (CRI/APN/617/04) [2004] LSHC 138 (08 November 2004);

July 2004

Motoboli v Matete and Another (CIV/APN/288/04) (CIV/APN/288/04) [2004] LSHC 85 (07 July 2004);

August 2004

Malataliana v Chairman PSC and Others (CIV/APN/355/03 ) (CIV/APN/355/03) [2004] LSHC 93 (04 August 2004);

April 2004

Makula and Another v Motinyane (CRI/APN/720/03) (CRI/APN/720/03) [2004] LSHC 65 (23 April 2004);

May 2004

Makhoali v Public Service Commission and Others (CIV/APN/378/2002 ) (CIV/APN/378/2002) [2004] LSHC 69 (12 May 2004);

April 2004

Judicial Service Commission and Others v Chobokoane (C of A (CIV) 17/2003) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 58 (07 April 2004);

March 2004

R v Ntheri and Another (CRI/T/154/2004 ) (CRI/T/154/2004) [2004] LSHC 41 (04 March 2004);

August 2004

Jane v Learned Magistrate (L Nthab1) and Others (CIV/APN/477/2004) (CIV/APN/477/2004) [2004] LSHC 103 (26 August 2004);

October 2004

R v Mankoe (Rev. Case No 172/2004 CR 323/003 Rev. Order No 22/2004 ) (NULL) [2004] LSHC 119 (13 October 2004);

April 2004

Baitsokoli and Another v Maseru City Council and Others (CONST/C/1/2004) (CONST/C/1/2004) [2004] LSHC 12 (25 April 2004);